CPSC 502 - Fall 2013
                          Review Form

Please email the completed form to David (poole@cs.ubc.ca) within 48
hours of the presentation.

Please give constructive feedback for the presenters. Expand on your
evaluation; give more than one word answers. The presenters will see all
of this form.

Presenters:
Title:

PRESENTATION:

What the presentation well organized? 


Was it clear what problem was being solved?


Was the background explained at an appropriate level of detail?


Were the results in the papers clearly explained?



For each presenter: 

Was the presentation clear? 


Were they well prepared?


Did they answer questions clearly? 


Did they make the topic interesting?


Give suggestions for their next presentation (things they did right,
as well as things that can be improved).



PAPER:

What needs to be expanded on for the paper? What can the author assume that
the reader already knows?


Do you know of any work that the paper should also refer to?


Any other advice on the paper?


YOUR RECOMMENDATION:

If you were grading the presentation for a graduate level course, what
mark would you give it (out of 20)?

What is your confidence in your evaluation? (Use words to describe
your confidence.)