Instructions and Tips for Paper Presentation A paper presentation will have three parties driving it: the presenter, the discussion leader, and the rest, acting as audience.Everyone should present paper(s) and should lead the discussion on paper(s) presented by someone else. Thus, for different papers, your roles may change.
must read every paper, ahead of its presentation. The audience for a
paper presentation should email the presenter and the discussion leader
a list of key questions on the paper, NO LATER THAN 5 PM the
day before the presentation. The discussion leader will consolidate the
questions into a google document and share it with the presenter and
with me, ahead of the presentation. The idea is for the presenter and
the discussion leader prepare careful answers to those questions.
the names suggest, the presenter will present the paper and discussion
leader will manage and steer the discussion, including Q&A, on the
follow are some instructions and tips on what to look for when reading
papers, how to give effective talks, and links to related resources.
presenter has to summarize the problem(s) studied in the paper, the
motivation, the contributions, and highlight the methodology/techniques
developed/used to solve the problem. In addition, they should make a
case for why the paper has merit and articulate value of the
contributions. What was missed by the authors or wasn’t addressed well
Some guidelines for preparing for paper presentations and for leading discussions may be found at Guidelines for Speakers and Discussion Leaders.
- Not a “straight” linear presentation.
- Should be a critique.
- Should get people excited/thinking about the paper.
- Not too superficial and not too dragging through the mud.